Part of our 10 for when series:
substance use Disorder
I used to think there were only two buckets:
“No Big Deal” or “Addict.”
Turns out, it’s not that simple.
Substance use disorders exist on a spectrum.
The language we use can shape whether we respond with blame or with care.
If you’re questioning your own relationship with drugs or alcohol, you don’t have to prove you have a problem before you ask for help.
The following examples describe past thought patterns - not recommended use strategies. Combining substances can carry serious health risks.
I can stop whenever I want.
If that person doesn’t have a problem, neither do I.
If that person has a problem, that doesn’t mean I do — I’m not that bad.
I’m just stressed.
I’m just having fun.
Last night I didn’t drink too much, and I’m not hungover today, so clearly this isn’t a problem.
Last night I drank way too much and mixed it with [fill in the blank.] I’m never doing that again, so obviously it’s not a problem.
What will they think of me if I stop?
These are just some of the recurring thoughts I’ve had surrounding my use of drugs and alcohol.
And then there were the rules.
From now on, I’ll just have one or two.
I just need to make sure I eat first.
I just need to make sure I drink enough water between drinks.
I just need to make sure I’m only drinking when I’m happy.
These are just some of the rules I tried to put in place over the years in an attempt to continue using drugs and alcohol, despite the harm it was causing me.
Why would I do that?
Because, in the moment, it was fun. And for me, it was easier than facing a truth I didn’t particularly want to face: my use of drugs and alcohol was causing me more harm than good.
While I haven’t been clinically diagnosed, I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that I meet the criteria for a substance use disorder.
I’m intentionally using the term substance use disorder instead of addiction. Not because addiction is necessarily the wrong word, or because everyone experiences it negatively, but because words carry different meanings and associations for different people.
For me, the word addiction came with a lot of shame. I had a very specific picture of what it meant to be an “addict,” and as long as I didn’t see myself in that picture, I could convince myself I didn’t have a problem.
Looking back, that language may have made it harder for me to recognize the harm I was experiencing.
And that’s worth talking about.
10 for When is a monthly series dedicated to one mental health topic at a time, with ten practical resources you can save, share, and come back to whenever they’re useful.
This month’s focus: SUBSTANCE use disorder
What Is Substance Use Disorder?
According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), substance use disorders (SUDs) are health conditions involving patterns of substance use that can affect a person’s brain, behavior, health, and daily life.
Repeated substance use can affect brain systems involved in reward, motivation, and self-control. For some people, these changes contribute to cravings, difficulty controlling use, and continued substance use despite harmful consequences.
Importantly, not everyone who uses drugs or alcohol develops a substance use disorder. And not everyone who experiences harm from substance use meets the criteria for one.
Substance use disorder is a clinical diagnosis, not a judgment about someone’s character, willpower, or worth.
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR) identifies ten classes of substances within its broader category of substance-related and addictive disorders:
Alcohol
Caffeine intoxication and caffeine withdrawal
Cannabis
Hallucinogens
Inhalants
Opioids
Sedatives, hypnotics, and anxiolytics
Stimulants, including cocaine and amphetamine-type substances
Tobacco
Other or unknown substances
These categories aren’t all treated identically for diagnostic purposes. For example, caffeine intoxication and withdrawal are recognized, but caffeine use disorder is not an established DSM-5-TR diagnosis.
Substance use disorders are generally classified as mild, moderate, or severe, depending on how many diagnostic criteria are met.
That distinction matters. It means we don’t have to rely on a single, all-or-nothing idea of what having a problem looks like.
And for someone like me, that was a pretty significant shift.
Mixed Messages: What I Learned About Drugs and Alcohol Growing Up
As a teen, one of my parents informed me that some drugs and some alcohol were okay, while others were off limits.
My other parent told me I was forbidden from trying any amount of drugs or alcohol, and that if I did, not only would I be punished, but I would likely become addicted and die.
This was incredibly confusing and, admittedly, to my teenage brain, just a little bit exhilarating.
Would I end up in the “no big deal” bucket or the “trying drugs makes me an addict” bucket?
I figured if I tried hard enough, I could live in the former.
These opposing viewpoints weren’t unique to me and my family, though.
For years, messages about drugs and alcohol have come from teachers, religious leaders, authority figures, doctors, researchers, friends and social circles, family members, straight-edge groups, partiers, ravers and festivalgoers, plant medicine shamans, rehab owners, the rich, and the poor.
Some messages emphasize abstinence. Others focus on moderation, personal freedom, harm reduction, or treatment. Some come from clinical research. Others come from personal experience, cultural beliefs, moral convictions, or commercial interests.
And sometimes those messages contradict each other.
The research continues to evolve as we learn more about how different substances affect the brain and body, why some people develop substance use disorders, and which approaches to prevention and treatment are effective.
But when you’re young and trying to figure out where you fit, all those competing messages can make it difficult to separate what is known from what is believed.
At least, that’s how it felt to me.
The Truth About Substance Use: It’s More Complicated Than Two Buckets
It isn’t surprising, then, that after those earlier experiences, it took me a while to arrive at a more nuanced understanding.
Here’s what I’ve come to recognize, both through personal experience and through learning more about substance use:
Drugs and alcohol can feel fun, and they can also be harmful. Enjoyment and risk aren’t mutually exclusive. A substance can feel rewarding in the moment while contributing to serious consequences over time.
Drugs and alcohol affect people differently. The likelihood of experiencing harm or developing a substance use disorder depends on multiple factors, including the substance, frequency and amount of use, age, genetics, mental health, environment, and individual circumstances.
There is help available if substance use becomes harmful. Evidence-based treatment, peer support, medications for certain substance use disorders, and harm-reduction services can make a meaningful difference. Recovery and improved health are possible, although outcomes vary and substance use can sometimes have fatal consequences.
The illicit drug supply carries serious and sometimes unpredictable risks. Not all counterfeit pills or illegally manufactured drugs contain fentanyl, but some may contain fentanyl or other unexpected substances, making it difficult to know exactly what someone is taking. Fentanyl is a powerful synthetic opioid that can cause a fatal overdose, even with a first exposure. Naloxone (Narcan) can reverse opioid overdoses, including those involving fentanyl, but it does not reverse overdoses caused solely by non-opioid substances. If an overdose is suspected, administer naloxone if available and call 911 immediately. Emergency medical care remains essential.
Avoiding substance use eliminates the risk of developing a disorder related to those substances. However, everyone’s risk is different, and support is available without judgment.
What I’ve learned is that the conversation doesn’t have to begin and end with whether someone is an “addict.”
It can begin with a much more useful question:
Is my relationship with this substance affecting my life in ways I don’t want it to?
The Facts: How Common Is Substance Use Disorder?
According to SAMHSA’s 2024 National Survey on Drug Use and Health, 16.8% of people in the United States aged 12 or older, approximately 48.4 million people, experienced a substance use disorder in the past year.
That’s roughly one in six people.
As a teen and young adult, hearing a statistic like that would have felt like a possibility, but for other people. Not for me or the people I knew.
As an adult, though, having experienced and witnessed struggles with substances, that number is felt rather than just heard.
It’s no longer an abstract statistic.
It’s people.
And the research tells us a few other important things:
Substance use disorders show up on a range. A person may experience mild, moderate, or severe use based on the number of diagnostic criteria met.
Recognizing harm doesn’t always make changing behavior easy. People may continue using substances despite wanting to reduce or stop, and difficulty changing can be part of the disorder.
Harm reduction is possible even while still using substances. This approach helps people lower risk and improve their health without requiring them to stop using substances to receive support.
Not everyone who uses substances develops a substance use disorder. Substance use and substance use disorder are not interchangeable.
Risk involves a combination of genetic, biological, psychological, and environmental factors. No single factor determines whether someone will develop a disorder.
Genetics play a meaningful role. Research suggests inherited factors account for approximately 40% to 60% of the variation in vulnerability to substance use disorders across populations. That doesn’t mean an individual’s future is 50% predetermined by their genes.
Early adversity and trauma can increase vulnerability. Childhood trauma, chronic stress, and adverse experiences are associated with increased risk, although they do not inevitably lead to substance use disorders.
Starting substance use at a younger age is associated with greater risk. Early initiation, including before age 14, is associated with a higher likelihood of later substance-related problems. That relationship is influenced by other developmental and environmental factors as well.
Mental health conditions can overlap with substance use disorders. Depression, anxiety, and other mental health conditions may coexist with SUDs, and the relationships between them can work in multiple directions.
Having one or several risk factors doesn’t mean someone will develop a substance use disorder.
And having a substance use disorder doesn't mean someone necessarily experienced trauma, has a mental health condition, or has a family history of substance-related problems.
There isn't one story, one cause, or one type of person.
But age can play an important role in vulnerability. Adolescence is a period of significant brain development, particularly in areas involved in decision-making, impulse control, and evaluating risks. Research shows that starting to use alcohol or other substances at a younger age is associated with a greater risk of developing substance-related problems later in life. According to the CDC, underage drinking also carries immediate health and safety risks, including injuries, impaired judgment, and other harmful consequences.
The encouraging part? Substance use disorders are treatable health conditions, not personal failures or inevitable outcomes. Evidence-based treatment, supportive relationships, and early intervention can make a meaningful difference. And the sooner someone feels comfortable asking questions or seeking support, the more opportunities there may be to prevent harm.
Risk isn't destiny. And needing help doesn't mean you've run out of options.
Other Sources:
NIH, Alcohol and the Adolescent Brain
SAMHSA, 2024 National Survey on Drug Use and Health
Do I Have Substance Use Disorder? Understanding the Signs
Only a qualified healthcare professional can diagnose a substance use disorder. But the diagnostic criteria are publicly available, and understanding them can be a useful starting point.
Under the DSM-5-TR, substance use disorders are generally assessed using 11 criteria that consider patterns of use and their consequences over a 12-month period.
These include:
Using a substance in larger amounts or for longer than intended.
Wanting to cut down or stop but having difficulty doing so.
Spending substantial time obtaining, using, or recovering from a substance.
Experiencing strong cravings or urges to use.
Having substance use interfere with responsibilities at work, school, or home.
Continuing to use despite recurring social or relationship problems.
Giving up or reducing important activities because of substance use.
Using substances in situations where doing so is physically dangerous.
Continuing to use despite knowing it may be causing or worsening physical or psychological problems.
Developing tolerance, meaning more of a substance may be needed to achieve the same effect.
Experiencing withdrawal symptoms when use is reduced or stopped.
Some criteria have important exceptions. For example, tolerance and withdrawal occurring during appropriately supervised medical treatment are not, by themselves, sufficient to establish a substance use disorder.
Generally, meeting two or three applicable criteria indicates a mild disorder, four or five indicates a moderate disorder, and six or more indicates a severe disorder.
A professional assessment considers the full clinical picture, including which substance is involved.
These criteria aren’t meant to be a self-diagnosis checklist. They’re a framework for understanding patterns that may deserve attention.
And you don’t need to meet two criteria, or any particular number, to decide that something about your substance use isn’t working for you.
For me, that distinction matters.
Why the Language Around Addiction Matters to Me
At 17, I was introduced to Alcoholics Anonymous, or AA.
It was there that - being young and quick to generalize for the sake of understanding something - I came away with my own view that you were either an alcoholic or you weren’t.
To be clear, that’s how I experienced and interpreted the language at the time. AA groups and individual members aren’t all identical, and many people find tremendous value, connection, and long-term support through the program.
But for me, at that age, the distinction felt black and white.
And just like the word addiction, it became another barrier to acknowledging where I was struggling.
I was focused on whether I qualified for a label rather than whether my relationship with alcohol and drugs was causing harm.
Of course, not everything in life is black and white.
And while clinical diagnostic thresholds are important, the recognition that substance use disorders can range from mild to severe creates room for a more nuanced conversation.
Room for the gray.
Had I understood that when I was younger, maybe I would have been able to recognize what was happening and seek support sooner.
I can’t know that for certain.
But I do wonder.
You Don’t Have to Prove You Have a Problem to Ask for Help
Eventually, I stopped trying to prove which bucket I belonged in.
I finally realized my time was better spent learning about myself, understanding my relationship with substances, and making changes where I wanted change.
That didn’t require me to settle on an identity or win an argument with myself about whether things were “bad enough.”
And now I have language that helps me describe what I experienced.
I still haven’t received a clinical diagnosis. I wouldn’t be surprised to learn that I meet the criteria for substance use disorder, but that’s something a qualified professional would need to assess.
And if I do?
There’s no shame in that.
Substance use disorder is a health condition, not a moral failing. And seeking support isn’t reserved for people who have reached a crisis point.
You can ask questions before things get worse.
You can explore moderation, reducing use, abstinence, or treatment options with a qualified professional, depending on your circumstances and the substance involved.
You can change your relationship with drugs or alcohol without needing to adopt a particular label.
And you can ask for help even if you’re still figuring out what you want that help to look like.
One important safety note: If you’ve been drinking heavily or regularly, or using certain medications such as benzodiazepines, stopping suddenly can cause dangerous withdrawal. Speak with a healthcare professional before abruptly discontinuing use if physical dependence may be present.
If you’re curious about your substance use, you don’t have to prove you have a problem before you’re allowed to ask for help.
There’s no bucket you have to fit into.
A doctor, therapist, addiction specialist, or the SAMHSA National Helpline at 1-800-662-HELP (4357) can help you explore available support and treatment resources.
And there’s no shame in asking.
if you’re struggling with substance use disorder - view our list of 10 for When.
10 for When is your go-to swipe sheet of tools, resources, and support for the moments when the hard stuff shows up, because it will. Consider this your standing invitation to be a little more ready than you were yesterday.
Disclaimer: This blog is not meant as professional advice or counseling. If you are in emotional distress or experiencing thoughts of harm to yourself or others, help is available 24/7:
If in crisis, call 988
Text HELLO to 741741 to connect with a Crisis Text Line counselor
Call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline:
1–800–273–8255 (TALK) Spanish & English
Deaf & Hard of Hearing TTY 800–799–4889
Call 911
If you need mental health treatment but cannot afford it, contact Rise Above The Disorder, a 501(c)(3) non-profit dedicated to making mental health care accessible to everyone: YouAreRAD.org